Hello!
After months of constant emails from people who have watched my Challah braiding video on YouTube asking for my challah recipe, I decided to reopen my blog. I love blogging, actually, but my life has gotten so hectic I can barely keep up with it.
There are some questions that seem to come up fairly regularly, so I’ll try to address them here.
Bread Machines – I have never used a bread machine. I would rather make Challah each Friday the “old fashioned way” simply because I like to. Nothing against Bread Machines. This means I have no idea how a bread machine might affect my recipe. I’m sorry, but I guess you’ll have to have fun experimenting to see what works for you.
Baking Stones – The baking stones I use in the video are at least 16-17 years old. They are very dark because I’ve used them for so many different things, and of course, I use them every Friday. I bought the round one through a Pampered Chef party AGES ago and the rectangular one from a local store, Fred Meyer. Both have been great and I can’t imagine baking Challah without them. However, I do have silicone loaf pans and they are excellent as well, but for the braided loaves, I use the stones.
Round Challot – I bake round Challot for Rosh Hashanah each year. There is no mystery to it. Take the regular Challah recipe on my blog (or the Cinnamon Raisin recipe) and instead of making two loaves, you separate the entire lump of dough into six very long “ropes”. Braid as you would a giant Challah, but try to stretch it out as long as you can. You’ll need the length in order to bring it around and attach the ends together to make a ring. Having a film of flour under it will help you to move it about on the countertop easily. Transferring it to the stone can be tricky, but don’t despair or think there is some easier way that you should have figured out by now. There IS no easy way. Suffer with the rest of us.
Challah Recipes – I experimented for several years before I settled on our family recipe for Challah. For a while, our family went total “low-carb” and I even had developed a low-carb version of Challah (I think I still have the recipe and pictures, but don’t let my family know this). We were so desperate for something that looked and smelled like bread we put up with it for three years. We suffered, but not in silence. Anyhow, the current recipe is a compromise because some of us unlucky members of the clan experience insulin resistance. Lucky us. Despite it’s obvious high-carb content due to the flour used, it is sugar free. Traditional Challah would normally have honey in the recipe. If you want one with honey, there are thousands of Challah recipes on the internet, just let your fingers Google, or Bing, or…whatever.
Freezing Challot - Challah freezes really well. If you know you won’t have time to bake on Friday before Shabbat, you can bake the Challah any day of the week. Just bake, let completely cool, then wrap it up in foil and freeze. When you want to warm it up, take it out of the freezer and let it sit on the counter all day. Before Shabbat, when your oven is warm, put the Challot in the oven and let it warm up for about twenty minutes. It should come out as fresh and aromatic as if you pulled it out of the oven freshly-baked. There’s no exact science to this, so you may want to open up the foil and check it now and then to make sure it really does heat through and, alternatively, that it doesn’t get too hot and turn hard and crispy.
Challah French Toast – French toasty goodness. There’s NO better French Toast than when it’s made with Challah.
So, there you have it.
Happy Baking!
~Maya


Help needed on Challah recipe. We have tried the Maya recipe twice. Both times the taste is great, but the loaves come out too dry. Cooking @ 350 for 45min. The outside toward the ends are almost stale/hard. Crust flakes excessively. Inside lacks that soft fresh feel. Any suggestions on how to modify the recipe or cooking time to get it right ?
Dear Dave,
I’m very sorry you’ve had so much trouble with the recipe. I am unsure why your Challah is turning out the way it is.
There are some things that can alter recipes. For instance, geographical elevation/altitude can change how things are baked and at what temperature. I’m at 500ft above sea level, are you living at a high altitude?
Here is a link to an article that talks about baking bread at high altitude (scroll down to the bottom of the article for “yeast breads”)
http://www.epicurious.com/articlesguides/howtocook/primers/altitudebaking_basics
Also, I use a gas oven which typically has more moisture, whereas an electric oven produces dry heat.
What kind of flour are you using? Is it all-purpose or bread flour? I’m not an expert, but there may be some differences there. I typically use all-purpose flour.
Lastly, what is your dough like when you set it to rise the first time? I leave mine just a bit sticky/moist so that it isn’t too dry later.
These are all the things I can think of. I’m sorry I can’t be of more help.
~Maya
Maya
I found your video today, I am so excited for this first Shabbat of 2010…anyway try my best to do the 6 braid..I need more practice..lol! I guess I can get some ropes and practice. Hopefully next Shabbat will be better, is raising again and can’t wait to try it out tonight.
Thanks for the beautiful video! You are gorgeous!
Dear Enid,
It takes some time to get comfortable braiding Challah. Be gentle with yourself. I’ve been doing it for nearly twenty years.
Thank you for the compliment. Wow. That made my day! LOL
Let me try posting this link to the Bread Machine recipe I have adapted (not from Maya’s recipe…from somewhere else) and used for a couple years now.
http://www.facebook.com/note.php?saved&&suggest¬e_id=59599864968
It is a half wheat/half white flour recipe and I have yet to try a sugar substitute variation. I have owned two bread machines over the course of adapting this recipe and suspect that every bread machine is a little different. If it doesn’t come out just right, try playing around with the liquid:solid ratio. The dough should be slightly sticky to touch but not so sticky that it comes off on your finger–just like making bread by hand. Watch the kneading process and add flour or water as necessary. The dough should be a nice ball yet not stick to the side of the pan about half way through the first mix/knead cycle.
A pal urged me to look at this page, nice post, interesting read… keep up the nice work!
So glad you are still here!! I have used your Challah recipe for a few years now. I recently moved overseas and can no longer be dependant on my mother in law for her great cooking, Your recipes are great!!! I will attempt your Sufganiyot this year!!!
Cuppie,
(The Sufganiyot are still being perfected in our household, however, they are luscious!
)
I’m glad this blog has been of some help!
I think we’ve got the perfect apron for all of these challah makers, from the mythical International Order of Challah Makers:
http://www.cafepress.com/JewnionLabel/7049901
Enjoy.
What type of flour are you using? All purpose, bread, whole wheat?
Thank you for the video – that really helps! Love your blog!
Greetings from Malaysia. I came across your YouTube video on how to do a six-strand braided challah today. I’ve been looking for clear instructions on how to do this for some time now and the video was a great help. Thank you! I will be posting about my own attempt soon and will of course link to your site.
First, thanks for the clear video — it’s such a wonderful organized improvement over my attempts to let my subconscious figure out the braid.
I wonder if I can ask for some help. A friend is getting married this Sunday in a country ceremony. I promised to provide a giant challah. I’m experienced with regular-sized challah, but this will be a first. I’m planning just to make three batches of challah dough, and then just braiding and braiding until it’s all one loaf. Maybe bake it in a slightly slower oven. Are there any secrets to making giant challahs?
Dear Garry,
I’m glad the video is helpful.
While I’ve never done what I consider a “giant Challah”, I can think of a couple things to consider. The bigger the challah, the more time it will need in the oven, but it sounds like you already know this, especially if you are going to bake it at a lower temperature.
I’m not sure about the length and the space you’d have in your oven. I have made really large round challot for Rosh Hashana and because they were round, I was able to fit them in the oven just fine. They are also very pretty this way.
Other than this, I cannot think of any “secrets”. May the wedding go well and may your Challah be beautiful and tasty!
When you say Cinnamon in the Challah, do you mean Cinnamon from the spice bottle or Cinnamon mixed w sweetener?
Hi Ben,
It would be ground cinnamon from the spice bottle.
I also noticed that we differ in the ingredients as I have butter and vanilla. but my recipe has some other significant added steps
ben
Hi Maya,
Thanks so much for all of your helpful hints. I’m wondering if you could provide some guidance to stick the ends of the round challah together without using toothpicks.
Chag sameach,
Julie
Julie, hello!
For me, braiding the ends of the round challah is always a dubious enterprise. I do the best I can to make it LOOK like they are perfectly braided and if they decide they don’t wish to hold together, I use the toothpicks. They really do disappear into the loaves and I can generally tell where the ends meet so I am just careful when slicing and serving the challah so no one gets one poking in their mouth.
There may very well be a better way, but this is what I do. Good luck!
Dear Maya
I am looking for the recipe of challot that you make the dough, shape them then freez them. When you take them out of the reezer, you have to leave them at least 8 hours to defrost and raise. they come out so light, high and very testy. In our Chabbad, they sell these challot and the Rabentze gets them from London.
Pleae can you give me the recipe of this dough or the tips to keep them light and high?
thanks
Tammar
Tammar,
I wish I knew of such a recipe. I’m sorry. I have only fully baked my challot and then frozen them. Later, I simply let the baked challot thaw out and warm in the oven and they smell and taste as though I baked it just then. I’m sorry I cannot help you.
~Maya
DEAR MAYA HI my name is LOURDES I am a hispanic christian woman. Just wanted to say thank you for posting the video on how to braid the challah bread. I am going to try it for the first time wish me luck. Maya I am learning on what is the meaning of the SABBATH DAY(THE LORD HOLY DAY) WITH ALL DO RESPECT TO YOU AND YOUR FAMILY. It will be a blessing to learn ALL about YOUR FAMILYS CELEBRATION, FESTIVAL AND ALL THE TRADITIONES. WILL YOU HELP ME. THANK YOU. IN YERUSHALAM THEY SHALL YIR’U SHALOM. SHALOM FRIEND
Dear Lourdes,
Thank you for your lovely comment.
There are many websites that will give you very good information on Shabbat observance as well as the high holy days. I don’t often post on this blog as I am extremely busy, but if you’d like to email me, feel free to and if you have any specific questions, I’ll do my best to answer them.
e mail : mayasprague at gmail . com (I type it this way to avoid spam mail)
May your challah be delicious!
~Maya